Greatest Total Down Jacket
Rab Electron Professional
Weight: 16.1 oz | Fill: Recycled 800-fill European goose down, Nikwax handled, RDS licensed
REASONS TO BUY
Comfy
Climate resistant
Nikwax-treated hydrophobic down
Harness pleasant pockets
Nice warmth-to-weight ratio
REASONS TO AVOID
No inner drop pockets
Not essentially the most packable
The Rab Electron Professional will preserve you heat and comfy on backcountry ski journeys or whereas layering up throughout stop-and-go winter actions. Rab stuffed this jacket with 800-fill, Nikwax-treated hydrophobic down. Whereas no down jacket can exchange a hardshell jacket or rain jacket, the Electron Professional fights the weather the most effective of any we examined. This extremely purposeful cold-weather workhorse matches rather well and was a favourite to put on throughout most actions amongst all our testers. It additionally has a bunch of nice adjustability and versatile options: an adjustable and pinchable waist hem, a helmet-compatible brimmed hood, elastic hood cinch cords with velcro on the again for micro-adjustments, and the hand pockets sit excessive and go deep so you should utilize them with a climbing harness or whereas sporting a hip belt. It has elastic strips sewn into the underside of the wrist cuffs that permit loads of stretch with out leaving a big elastic wristband uncovered to the weather.
In comparison with a number of the different down jackets we examined, the Electron Professional is fairly heavy and would not pack down very small. For a brilliant packable jacket, try the Mountain Hardwear Ghost Whisperer — simply know you will should sacrifice some heat. We want the Electron Professional had inner drop pockets for stashing gloves. However in the event you’re in search of an all-around superior jacket that may preserve you very heat with out including an excessive amount of weight, look no additional. If you would like loads of heat however are planning to put on an outer shell over high, we additionally love the nice and cozy Feathered Buddies Eos and the comfortable The North Face Summit Breithorn.
Learn extra: Rab Electron Professional overview
Greatest Worth Down Jacket for On a regular basis Use
REI Co-op 650 Down
Weight: 10.1 oz | Fill: 650-fill down, RDS licensed
REASONS TO BUY
Light-weight
Cheap
Comfy
Appears to be like nice
Inclusive sizing
REASONS TO AVOID
No hood
Not the warmest
The REI Co-op 650 Down prices a lot lower than lots of the different jackets we examined, but it has many of the similar nice options as jackets that price twice as a lot. This mannequin is top of the range, very comfy, and light-weight. It is versatile sufficient to put on round city and preserve sporting on the path. Plus, it is comfy sufficient that you simply will not need to take it off whenever you’re finished with all of it. It weighs a mere 10.1 ounces, making it one of many lightest jackets on this overview. It is a easy jacket and would not have too many further options, however that simplicity makes it an important possibility for on a regular basis put on and retains the worth extraordinarily inexpensive. It additionally is available in essentially the most sizes of any jacket we examined, so any physique form will be capable of discover a measurement that matches — from small by 3XL, in addition to L Tall, XL Tall, and XXL Tall.
Regardless of the 650 Down‘s general excessive efficiency, this is not the warmest jacket we examined. For a hotter jacket that is nonetheless within the sub-$200 vary, try the Columbia Delta Ridge Hooded. We do not discover it as comfy or breathable because the 650 Down, nevertheless it’s definitely hotter. The 650 can be one of many solely down jackets we examined and not using a hood — although there’s a hooded model of this jacket offered by REI for about $20 extra. Whereas it is fairly light-weight, it additionally would not have any packability options. We merely used the drop-in pocket as a stow spot, which works nice, however this jacket would not have a devoted stuff sack or double-sided zipper pocket for packing it away. And regardless of the dearth of a stuff sack, it is loads packable. If affordability and efficiency are on the high of your listing, there is no jacket we would suggest extra for on a regular basis put on at an inexpensive value.
Learn extra: REI Co-op 650 Down overview
An Inexpensive Alpine Jacket
Rab Microlight Alpine
Weight: 14.9 oz | Fill: Recycled 700-fill down, Nikwax handled, RDS licensed
REASONS TO BUY
Inexpensive
Wonderful alpine match
Recycled hydrophobic down
Layers nicely
REASONS TO AVOID
No drop-in pockets
Heavier than some jackets
The Rab Microlight Alpine is our high choose for an inexpensive jacket with all of the options you’d want in a real alpine jacket. This jacket is weather-resistant, heat, and extremely comfy. The 700-fill recycled down insulation has a hydrophobic coating, and the shell materials resists soaking by longer than many different puffies. It is heat sufficient to put on in chilly situations and has a superb cinch twine adjustable hood to seal in warmth round your head. The hood additionally has a sewn-in visor to maintain snow out of your eyes, and there is a cozy knit zipper storage inside to guard your chin when sporting the hood all day.
The Microlight Alpine is not essentially the most transportable jacket, nevertheless. At 14.9 ounces for a males’s small, that is heavier than many different jackets. This jacket matches rather well, is heat and weather-resistant sufficient for any alpine journey, and is extra inexpensive than many of the different high performers. For those who do not want the adventure-focused options, the inexpensive REI 650 and the comfy Patagonia Down Sweater Hoody are two of our favourite on a regular basis jackets.
Learn extra: Rab Microlight Alpine overview
Good Worth on a Very Restricted Funds
Wantdo Packable Down Hoody
Weight: 10.6 oz | Fill: 90% duck down, RDS licensed
REASONS TO BUY
Shockingly cheap
Light-weight
Very compressible
REASONS TO AVOID
Not essentially the most sturdy
Hand pocket zippers snag simply
Boxy match
Down puffies can get costly, however not the Wantdo Packable Down Hoody. This mannequin prices about half as a lot because the second most cheap down jacket in our testing lineup and fewer than 1 / 4 of a number of the priciest. It has a mean warmth-to-weight ratio and packs down into an included stuff sack. It is crammed with 90% duck down insulation and has a skinny outer shell with an adequately comfy liner. Whether or not you are heading to work or out for a day spent taking part in outdoors, a small and lightweight insulation layer like this one is a superb possibility to hold. It is simple to take with you wherever you go, simply in case. And it prices lower than a mean raise ticket, so it is onerous to go this deal up.
Although it is mild, packable, and inexpensive, the Wantdo would not have the identical premium options you’d discover on many different jackets. The zippers on the hand pockets are very small and snag simply. This makes them onerous to function bare-handed and almost not possible to make use of with gloves on. It is also one of many least heat jackets we examined. For those who plan on sporting your puffy loads, we expect spending somewhat extra for a extra comfy jacket just like the REI 650 or a hotter jacket just like the Columbia Delta Ridge Hooded is nicely price it. However for the worth, we could not not suggest the Wantdo for people residing in delicate climates or who solely want a down jacket for infrequent put on.
Ultracomfortable Heat
The North Face Summit Breithorn Hoodie
Weight: 15.2 oz | Fill: 800 fill ProDown, water-repellent, RDS licensed
REASONS TO BUY
Heat
Comfy
Water repellant down
Nice pockets
REASONS TO AVOID
Costly
Heavy
Since we final examined the Breithorn, The North Face has up to date the outer materials to 15D Pertex Y Fuse. This materials is recycled and encompasses a non-PFC DWR coating. The value has additionally elevated by $50. We’re linking to the up to date jacket in our overview.
The The North Face Summit Breithorn Hoodie is the jacket we seize once we want all-around heat and luxury. This is among the warmest and most comfy jackets we examined and has tons of distinctive options that make it a pleasure to put on. Its supple lining materials is a number of the softest feeling material in opposition to your pores and skin, and the wrist cuffs are comfy as nicely. They’re stretchy knit materials that looks like a well-worn T-shirt, in contrast to the easy elastic sewn into wrist cuffs of most different jackets. The hood adjusts with a single toggle on the again that tightens round your face edge after which twists to wrap across the again of your head. The result’s a brilliant easy one-handed adjustment to lock the hood in place. It additionally has essentially the most pockets of any mannequin we examined — seven! They embrace two zippered hand pockets, a zippered exterior chest pocket, two inner stretch mesh pockets, and two slip-in pockets behind these stretch mesh pockets.
The Summit Breithorn Hoodie has tons of nice options to maintain you heat and comfy when the temperature drops, nevertheless it’s comparatively heavy. At 15.2 ounces for a males’s small, it is definitely overkill for summer time backpacking situations. If you would like a jacket for excursions like that, try the Mountain Hardwear Ghost Whisperer, which is chillier however, at 8.3 ounces, is about half the load of the Breithorn. Nonetheless, the Breithorn jacket is a superb selection for all the things from mountain climbing and mountaineering to hanging across the campfire and strolling across the metropolis within the winter. If consolation is paramount for you and your pursuits do not embrace high-octane excursions, the Patagonia Down Sweater Hoody is one other beautifully cozy jacket that we love for on a regular basis put on, and it’s kind of extra inexpensive, too.
Learn extra: The North Face Summit Breithorn Hoodie overview
Greatest For Ultralight Adventures
Mountain Hardwear Ghost Whisperer
Weight: 8.3 oz | Fill: 800-fill goose down, RDS licensed
REASONS TO BUY
Ultralight
Athletic match
100% recycled ripstop nylon shell
Layers nicely
REASONS TO AVOID
Costly
Not many pockets
Little adjustability
Since our final check interval with this jacket, Mountain Hardwear has dropped the /2 from the title. It is now simply known as the Ghost Whisperer Down Hoody. Nonetheless, specs and options are very related (if not an identical) to the mannequin we examined right here.
The Mountain Hardwear Ghost Whisperer is the most effective down jacket when weight saving is your high precedence. At 8.3 ounces for a males’s small, it presents unbelievable packability. This mannequin simply packs into its pocket and compresses into the smallest measurement of any jacket we have discovered. That is our go-to layer for backpacking and alpine climbing, and it acts as a just-in-case layer that may virtually disappear into your pack whenever you aren’t sporting it. The athletic match accommodates broader shoulders, permitting for simple overhead motion, and it breathes higher than many jackets, so you may preserve sporting it as you progress quicker. Layering a lightweight fleece beneath proved simple, and the jacket’s tailor-made match retains it from feeling cumbersome whilst you’re energetic.
The Ghost Whisperer has simply two zippered hand pockets with no drawcord, no inside pockets, and no adjustment on the hood. Whereas the absence of those options makes it as mild as it’s, a further pocket and extra hood adjustment could be good in some situations. For those who’re not heading out on an mountain climbing expedition, the extra informal MontBell Superior Down is one other light-weight contender that is extra informal in its match and prices loads much less. Total, the Ghost Whisperer’s packability and unbelievable general efficiency make it an important possibility for anybody in search of an ultralight puffy jacket for adventuring.
Learn extra: Mountain Hardwear Ghost Whisperer overview
Greatest Insulated Jacket for Males
Patagonia DAS Mild Hoody
Weight: 12.31 oz |Fill: PlumaFill 100% recycled polyester
REASONS TO BUY
Very heat
Climate resistant exterior
Unfastened match works for layering
REASONS TO AVOID
Expensive
Troublesome to stow in pocket
Not breathable
For those who’d desire to skip the feathers, the Patagonia DAS Mild Hoody is a top-notch various to a down-filled jacket. This artificial coat presents wonderful heat and climate safety. It’s light-weight and constructed with 10D nylon ripstop Pertex Quantum, together with a DWR end. When hit with precipitation, water beads up on the outside and would not penetrate to the innermost layers. We cherished sporting this jacket because it was comfy and moved nicely with us. Whether or not we have been climbing or working errands round city, this jacket stored us cozy. Ought to it not be sufficient by itself to maintain you heat, the unfastened lower permits for layering beneath. Weighing in at simply 12.31 ounces, this coat is crammed with PlumaFill 100% recycled polyester. It boasts three zippered pockets, an adjustable hem, and a cinchable helmet-compatible hood. Whether or not headed out on a motorcycle trip or taking the canine for a stroll, that is one in every of our check staff’s favourite insulated jackets available on the market.
For prime-output actions, this jacket could be too heat. Whereas sporting the DAS Hoody, we acquired somewhat sweaty and had to make use of the twin zippers to dry off. Although it may match contained in the left-hand pocket, it is vitally tough to take action. We most popular to only stuff it in our backpacks as a substitute of messing with this characteristic. Moreover, this jacket is not essentially the most budget-friendly. As a substitute, we suggest the Amazon Necessities Light-weight Puffer for a wallet-happy, first rate insulated jacket.
Learn extra: Patagonia DAS Mild Hoody overview
Examine Merchandise
How We Take a look at Down Jackets
For this overview, we recognized the important thing metrics important to grading any down jacket. Then, we created a rigorous set of exams to carry out within the subject and within the check lab to check every of those metrics on their very own. Since 2010, we have bought essentially the most fascinating, most compelling jackets and pushed them to their limits all over the world, climbing, climbing, snowboarding, tenting, and even sleeping in them. We took them to frigid locations just like the Excessive Sierra, the Rockies, the Pacific Northwest, the Large Horn Mountains, and the Inexperienced Mountains.
To guage every, we wore each jacket again to again, in the identical situations on the identical day, and assessed which stored us the warmest whereas additionally inspecting which jackets had further insulation in areas vulnerable to warmth loss. Whereas sporting every jacket within the subject, we paid consideration to which have been essentially the most comfy and assessed how every felt on our naked pores and skin. We took each mannequin to the lab, spraying water on each jacket and rubbing it in to evaluate water resistance and placing every in opposition to a fan to learn how wind resistant they’re. We weighed each jacket and packed them into their pockets and stuff sacks. We wore them throughout sweaty actions like climbing and maintaining with the canine to find out how breathable they’re. See extra specifics on our testing course of in our How We Take a look at article.
We examined each jacket throughout 5 mutually unique metrics to take a deep dive into the efficiency of every mannequin. Listed below are our testing metrics for down jackets and some issues for every:
- Heat (30% of general weight): How heat and comfy is that this jacket? How thick and lofty is the down? Will it preserve me heat and guarded in numerous winter situations?
- Consolation (30% weight): How does this jacket feels in opposition to my pores and skin? How is the match? Is it restrictive once I transfer? Does it have further options that add consolation, like fleece lining?
- Portability (15% weight): How a lot does this jacket weigh? How packable is it? Is that this mild sufficient to hold in my pack into the backcountry or throw in a suitcase? Does it pack into its personal pocket? Does it include a stuff sack? Can it maintain as much as being ceaselessly compressed?
- Climate Resistance (15% weight) Does this jacket shield me from wind? Does it repel snow and lightweight rain? How nicely does the hood work for holding out the weather?
- Breathability (10% weight): Can I take advantage of this jacket whereas working, climbing, biking, snowboarding, or climbing with out overheating? Does it have any air flow options that assist handle warmth throughout high-output actions?
Why Belief GearLab
Our in-depth males’s down jacket testing is headed up by Sam Schild, a backpacker, path runner, and mountain biker primarily based in Colorado. He has backpacked the Pacific Crest Path, Continental Divide Path, Grand Enchantment Path, Arizona Path, and Colorado Path (3 times!), together with numerous different out of doors adventures, lengthy and brief, in each season. Sam is joined by a panel of skilled gear testers, together with James Lucas, Buck Yedor, and Adam Paashaus. Rising up in New England, James’s appreciation for high quality insulation began younger. After graduating from school, he labored for Yosemite Search and Rescue, the place he noticed firsthand that having the fitting outerwear might be the distinction between a pleasing time out within the mountains or needing a rescue. Over time, James has examined gear within the Atlas Mountains of Morocco, the boulders of Rocky Mountain Nationwide Park, and his house in Boulder, Colorado. Adam has been an energetic member of the out of doors neighborhood for a few years. His ardour for serving to others discover the fitting gear for his or her adventures began in 2001 when he began working within the retail facet of the business. He is had his arms on extra jackets than he can rely and is aware of the best way to assist of us discover the proper jacket for them.
We examined these jackets within the subject and the lab, on on a regular basis adventures and epic backcountry missions.
Evaluation and Take a look at Outcomes
All of the finalists in our lineup underwent our in depth, side-by-side testing that features all the things that makes up an important down jacket. We selected every contender primarily based on exhaustive analysis on innovation, high quality, and recognition, in addition to numerous different elements that make a top-quality down jacket. We purpose to present you sensible and thorough data so you may make the fitting buying resolution for your wants.
What is the Greatest Worth?
Spending tons of of {dollars} each season to have the newest innovation provides up shortly. In our testing, we constantly discover that worth typically comes with the next price ticket, however not at all times. Our high choose for a high-value jacket that performs nicely and would not break the financial institution is the REI Co-op 650 Down. This jacket balances value with consolation and flexibility higher than most.
The Wantdo Packable Down Hoody additionally presents unbelievable worth. This jacket comes at a startlingly low value — lower than half as a lot because the REI 650 prices. It is not as heat as many different fashions and would not carry out as nicely general, however that low value does make this an superior worth. Whereas not as cheap because the Wantdo Down Hoody, the Rokka and Rolla Extremely Light-weight Puffer and Columbia Delta Ridge Hooded are additionally notable for his or her low value, cheap performances in on a regular basis conditions and, due to this fact, excessive worth.
The Rab Microlight Alpine is one other nice worth possibility for many who want extra from their jacket. This coat presents unbelievable climate resistance and all the things else you’d need for a real alpine insulation piece at a really aggressive value. In the identical value vary because the Microlight Alpine, the Marmot Highlander and MontBell Superior Down each provide an important worth. We predict jackets on this value vary are an important selection since they’re normally well-made utilizing high-quality supplies in a no-frills method that retains prices low.
Some jackets are simply too costly for what they’re. A type of jackets is the Arc’teryx Cerium Hoody. Whereas it is an important jacket in lots of regards, it is also outperformed by cheaper fashions in each metric. Except you require that little fossilized emblem in your puffy, we expect there are better-value objects accessible.
Heat
Merely put, down jackets are designed to maintain you heat. That is what they’re designed to do. We assessed each mannequin’s heat in excessive winter situations — snowstorms, early morning mountain ascents, and lengthy winter nights backpacking within the winter desert. We made word of the kind of down insulation of every jacket and measured the thickness, and we wore each jacket throughout side-by-side testing to evaluate which of them truly stored us hotter in the identical situations.
We checked out how nicely you may layer beneath and on high of every jacket, and we checked out how nicely these jackets can cinch right down to seal in your physique’s warmth. Though they do not include temperature rankings like sleeping baggage, these jackets provide good-to-adequate standalone heat right down to freezing temperatures. They’ll additionally allow you to keep heat in decrease temperatures when used as a part of a layering system.
A jacket’s heat pertains to the scale of the baffles and the fill energy. Merely put, the puffier a jacket appears, the hotter it seemingly is. But it surely will get extra difficult than that. Down’s fill high quality, or fill energy, is set by filling a cylindrical container with one ounce of down after which compressing it for a minute. After the sixty seconds, the quantity of house crammed is taken into account the fill. So, 600 cubic inches of down equals 600-fill. 900-fill down is about pretty much as good because it will get. A lot of the jackets on this overview have 800-fill energy down.
The heat of a jacket is then decided not solely by the standard of the fill but in addition by the quantity of it. Larger high quality down means extra loft per ounce of down, and extra loft is hotter. So, the next fill-power jacket can be puffier however weigh much less and be hotter than a decrease fill-power jacket.
The Feathered Buddies Eos, with 900+ fill energy goose down, has the very best fill energy and highest high quality down of any jacket we examined (goose down is extra insulating than duck down). This jacket could be very heat contemplating the load, and it is because it is thickly full of high-quality 900+ fill down.
The Arc’teryx Cerium Hoody is full of 850-fill down. This jacket is nearly as heat because the Feathered Buddies Eos. But it surely would not have fairly as a lot loft and is not fairly as thick, so it is not as heat. Jackets utilizing a decrease fill energy sacrifice weight and compressibility however can nonetheless present a warmth-to-weight ratio that outperforms artificial insulation jackets.
The Rab Electron Professional and The North Face Summit Breithorn Hoodie each use 800-fill down — and a lot of it — to insulate you. As a result of these fashions are each so thickly crammed, they’re impressively heat, even in comparison with fashions with larger fill energy down. They each weigh considerably greater than the Feathered Buddies Eos or Arc’teryx Cerium Hoody, largely as a result of they include extra down and are literally hotter than these higher-fill energy jackets.
Most firms produce lighter, cheaper down jackets by utilizing sewn-through baffle building. The baffles, the cavities between the stitching, maintain the down in place, holding it from sinking or clumping. Sewn-through baffle building includes stitching the outer material to the internal material, making a horizontal or often sq. baffle. The dimensions of the baffles varies between jackets, and sq. baffles are typically lighter, thinner, and cheaper. Nonetheless, sewn-through baffles create skinny spots on the seams the place there is no down, and heat air can escape. Some firms use totally different strategies for stitching baffles, however the sewn-through technique tends to be the commonest.
Columbia Delta Ridge Hooded makes use of welded baffle seams and a thermally reflective lining to create a remarkably heat jacket
The Columbia Delta Ridge Hooded jacket has welded seams to create the baffles. This implies there aren’t tiny holes from stitching the baffles, although there are nonetheless skinny spots the place the 2 layers of material are bonded. This jacket additionally has a thermally reflective lining that bounces your physique warmth again at you, although, and the results of these options is a really heat jacket.
The loft of a jacket makes up a part of a jacket’s heat, whereas the lower and adjustability make up one other portion. Slim, thermally environment friendly jackets and people with an extended hemline are typically hotter. The Mountain Hardwear Ghost Whisperer is not the warmest jacket, nevertheless it’s fairly heat contemplating how little it weighs. The trim, thermally environment friendly match definitely has one thing to do with this jacket punching above its weight class by way of heat.
Up to now few years, most firms have began utilizing licensed Responsibly Sourced Down. Harvesting down from geese and geese could be a merciless course of. To be RDS licensed, the animals have to be handled compassionately.
The one jacket on this lineup that is not RDS licensed is the MontBell Superior Down. Based on MontBell’s web site, they supply their down from the meat business. So, whereas these feathers aren’t plucked off of reside birds, they don’t seem to be RDS licensed. You may make your personal judgments on the moral implications right here.
Consolation
If a jacket is not comfy to put on, then are you even going to make use of it? In all probability not. We examined consolation by assessing the match of every jacket on totally different physique shapes and the sensation of the material in opposition to our pores and skin.
We took cautious word of how high-touch areas, akin to the within of the hood and the highest of the zipper, felt in opposition to our naked pores and skin. We additionally assessed how nicely every jacket match, noting any restrictions to the actions you’d make throughout actions like climbing, chasing the children on the park, commuting by bike, and even snowboarding.
Essentially the most comfy jackets have been the Rab Electron Professional and Patagonia Down Sweater Hoody. Each of those jackets have an especially comfy material really feel in opposition to your naked pores and skin. The Electron Professional has a number of the most comfy wrist cuffs and knit material on the within of the hood, which makes it that rather more comfy. The Down Sweater would not have any further comfy options in-built, however the match for the boys’s model is about as near good as we discovered. This superior match, paired with the softest material of any we examined, makes this jacket a pleasure to put on all day lengthy.
This appears apparent once we write it down, however simply because the boys’s model of a jacket matches males rather well does not imply that the ladies’s model goes to suit girls as nicely. All our male testers discovered the match of the Marmot Highlander was too boxy to be very comfy, and the Patagonia Down Sweater Hoody match so nicely that it almost earned an ideal rating in our consolation metric. Then again, our feminine testers of down jackets for girls discovered the other was true of the match of those jackets. Our girl testing staff discovered that the ladies’s Marmot Highlander match almost completely, whereas the ladies’s Patagonia Down Sweater Hoody simply did not match proper. So, simply because we’re saying a specific males’s jacket matches rather well, that does not imply the corresponding girls’s model will match as nicely.
As a remaining word, all our bodies are totally different, and we won’t probably assess how nicely any jacket will match everybody, irrespective of what number of testers we have now put on these jackets.
The The North Face Summit Breithorn Hoodie and Rab Microlight Alpine have been every nearly as comfy because the Rab Electron and Patagonia Down Sweater. The Summit Breithorn Hoodie has stretchy and delicate knit wrist cuffs and a knit edge alongside the surface seam of the hood, the place it may rub in opposition to your cheeks. The Rab Microlight matches rather well, has a snug knit zipper storage to stop your chin from chafing in chilly situations, and has the same feeling material to the opposite most comfy jackets.
A super-fitting jacket mimics the physique’s form in order that it strikes as we do but in addition options sufficient house giant sufficient to put on a layer beneath it. Sleeve size and the form by the shoulders, higher again, and chest additionally have an effect on consolation. We would like jackets prepared for mountain climbing, backpacking, climbing, snowboarding, scrambling, or any exercise the place we’re more likely to be transferring our arms about and swinging them over our heads. A lot of the jackets we examined work nicely as a part of a layering system in addition to a standalone piece. Generally, you will use a down jacket as a mid-layer, and typically, a down jacket serves as your outer layer with a fleece mid-layer beneath.
We discovered slimmer becoming jackets just like the Mountain Hardwear Ghost Whisperer match rather well over a skinny baselayer or brief sleeve shirt, however in the event you plan to layer thicker fleeces beneath, you may need to measurement one measurement up. This is not a difficulty, however it’s price noting. The identical is the case with the Rokka and Rolla Extremely Light-weight Puffer: if you wish to put on this over something greater than a T-shirt, we suggest getting a measurement bigger than you usually put on. This specific mannequin additionally had the shortest sleeves of any jacket in our overview, and allowed for the least vary of movement general.
Portability
Whereas portability barely issues whenever you’re sporting a jacket near house, the upper, additional, and steeper you enterprise, the extra each ounce issues. Within the backcountry, we prioritize weight to preserve power and permit us to get farther up the mountain. Thus, a jacket’s portability is a vital consideration for backpackers, vacationers, climbers, and anybody else who plans to hold the jacket of their pack at the very least a number of the time.
Generally, down is the most effective insulation materials for packability since it is vitally compressible, however some down jackets are nonetheless extra transportable than others. To check portability, we weighed each jacket. We packed and unpacked every mannequin repeatedly to see how nicely the materials held up over prolonged use and assessed which of them packed away the best.
Typically, down fill energy, the kind or weight of the material, the quantity of down, and the variety of options all have an effect on the load and portability of a down jacket. Utilizing larger fill-power down interprets to the next loft with much less filling, so larger fill-power jackets are typically lighter (or at the very least hotter) however costlier. Equally, thinner material could make a jacket lighter, however that thinner material can compromise sturdiness. Lastly, to save lots of weight, some fashions embrace fewer options or just use much less down. A jacket with chest pockets, burly zippers, a number of drawcords, and tons of down packed into each baffle goes to weigh greater than a jacket with two hand pockets, skinny baffles, and little else. Our chart under reveals our measured weights for every jacket we examined.
The Mountain Hardwear Ghost Whisperer, at 8.3 ounces in a measurement small, is essentially the most transportable jacket we examined. This mannequin would not have any hood adjustment options and solely has two zippered hand pockets. However, it packs into its personal pocket and is mild sufficient that we by no means hesitated to pack it simply in case. We use the Ghost Whisperer as the one heat layer we feature whereas backpacking, and you may’t do higher than this jacket if ultralight packability is your high concern.
The Feathered Buddies Eos is among the finest jackets you may get for heat in an especially transportable package deal. This jacket weighs solely 11.3 ounces but is nearly as heat because the warmest jackets we examined. The MontBell Superior Down weighs a mere 8.7 ounces, too, however we discovered this jacket wasn’t almost as heat because the Ghost Whisperer/2 and did not even evaluate to the Eos by way of heat.
The Rab Electron Professional and The North Face Summit Breithorn Hoodie are two of the heaviest jackets within the lineup. These jackets every weigh a few pound and are examples of how heat and weight are sometimes a tradeoff. Although the Ghost Whisperer is heat for its weight, it solely weighs half as a lot because the Electron Professional — however is not almost as heat as that ultra-thick jacket.
The Wantdo Packable and Rokka and Rolla Puffer are mild in your pack and in your pocketbook. These jackets weigh 10.6 and 9.2 ounces, respectively, although we fear in regards to the long-term sturdiness of those funds choices. They’re additionally not almost as heat, and we find yourself carrying extra layers when taking these jackets into significantly chilly locations, which negates any weight financial savings we get from them. But when delicate climates are your gig, their weight financial savings might swimsuit you nicely.
Besides in extraordinarily chilly situations, strenuous exercise causes overheating in down jackets. Meaning your puffy will spend a variety of time in your pack whenever you’re backpacking, snowboarding, or climbing. The superior compressibility of down jackets versus artificial ones is critical. Extra importantly, down’s sturdiness is bigger than artificial insulation, which degrades and loses its re-lofting capability over time. Taking weight and stuffability into consideration, our whole scores for the portability metric are proven under. The MHW Ghost Whisperer and MontBell jackets have been essentially the most transportable, whereas the Fjallraven was one of many heaviest and least packable fashions we examined.
A lot of the jackets in our overview use high-quality down that is still lofty, compression after compression. The dimensions and the way simply they pack away units the totally different jackets aside. Most fashions we examined stuff down into an inner pocket, whereas others include a stuff sack to pack it away.
Rab lately polled their buyer base and located that many individuals weren’t utilizing the stuff sacks they included with their jackets. To scale back waste, Rab determined to cease together with stuff sacks with many coats of their lineup, together with the Electron Professional and Microlight Alpine we examined for this overview. You should buy a stuff sack immediately from their web site in the event you actually need one.
The Feathered Buddies Eos, Wantdo Packable, Arc’teryx Cerium, Rokka and Rolla Light-weight Puffer, and MontBell Superior pack right into a stuff sack. Whereas we discovered it simpler to pack a down jacket right into a separate stuff sack than into its personal pocket, we do not love having to maintain monitor of a stuff sack whereas we’re sporting the coat.
A stowaway pocket with a reversible zipper cuts down on further weight and materials. It additionally means there is no stuff sack to lose. The jackets that pack into their very own pocket are the Out of doors Analysis Helium Down Hoodie, Marmot Highlander Hoody, Mountain Hardwear Ghost Whisperer, Patagonia Down Sweater Hoody, and The North Face Summit Breithorn Hoodie. Generally, we discovered it barely tougher to pack away jackets into an built-in stuff sack pocket than it was to pack jackets right into a separate stuff sack. It is notably tough to pack the Ghost Whisperer/2 into its personal pocket — and particularly difficult to shut the zipper.
Climate Resistance
Whilst you should not depend on a down jacket to remain dry, we would like to remain dry sufficient in a lightweight mist or when it is snowing. It is also crucial {that a} down jacket blocks the wind as a result of if the wind can lower by your jacket, it is not going to maintain you heat. We measured water and wind resistance for these causes.
Sporting a down jacket within the rain will shortly make you understand why all jackets aren’t product of light-weight insulation. Down fails to insulate when moist, and sporting a down jacket in a storm can go from uncomfortable to harmful as down takes a painfully very long time to dry and re-loft when saturated. Thankfully, designers have a number of methods for negating this vulnerability.
Drydown, ProDown, Downtec, and different “hydrophobic down” all claimed to have higher water resistance and quicker drying instances than untreated down. Evaluating the hydrophobic high quality of those handled downs is tough. Even after soaking jackets within the bathe, we discovered it tough to isolate the waterproofness of the down from different elements that add to every jacket’s water resistance. Nonetheless, we have now discovered that down with a hydrophobic remedy appears to remain drier for longer.
An amazing selection for moist climate, the Rab Microlight Alpine combines a water resistant Pertex microlight shell material with a powerful DWR coating, Nikwax handled down, and a brimmed hood that deflects rain. Whereas not waterproof, this down jacket works nicely in moist climates. The hotter and heavier-duty Rab Electron Professional sports activities the identical waterproofing know-how, performs about the identical in wetter situations, and has an much more protecting hood.
The Marmot Highlander additionally has water resistant handled down insulation. Nonetheless, it did not carry out as nicely once we put water immediately on the material and rubbed it with our arms. The TNF Summit Breithorn has down that is been handled with a water-repellent coating, and this jacket’s shell materials carried out higher than the Highlander in our spray and rub check.
The Out of doors Analysis Helium Down Hoodie can be comparatively climate resistant. It has a extra waterproof materials on the hood and the tops of the shoulders. This retains water off whereas the remainder of the jacket stays breathable.
Keep in mind that most folk aren’t taking a look at down merchandise for his or her water-resistance properties. This isn’t their meant objective, neither is any down jacket actually waterproof. We stress heat as the highest precedence when choosing a puffy. Nonetheless, a down jacket must be weather-resistant sufficient to guard you when it snows.
The chemical coating of a sturdy water-repellent (DWR) remedy causes water to bead and roll off the handled materials. Out of the field, DWR-treated fashions successfully preserve the down dry and lofty in mild rain. Sadly, these chemical substances lose their effectiveness because the jacket is worn. On a regular basis use exposes the shell material to grime and oils, inflicting spots on the jacket to “moist out,” particularly on the again of the neck and shoulders. Common cleansing prolongs the DWR remedy, and you may reapply sure DWR remedy with a product like Nikwax.
Whereas utilizing these jackets for on a regular basis actions offers you a way of how nicely every jacket blocks the wind, we additionally created a repeatable lab check to measure wind resistance. Utilizing a fan set to excessive, we positioned each jacket on high of the fan to really feel how a lot air handed by.
A lot of the jackets in our lineup did a superb job blocking the wind blowing by our check fan, however the Rab Electron Professional, The North Face Summit Breithorn, Rab Microlight Alpine, Arc’teryx Cerium Hoody, and Feathered Buddies Eos stood out essentially the most for his or her wind blocking properties.
Breathabilty
Whilst you need a jacket to maintain you heat, whenever you’re working onerous outdoors, you do not need to overheat, both. Because of this, it is essential {that a} down jacket is breathable sufficient so you do not work up a sweat when your physique is working tougher. Whether or not you are chasing your canine (who’s lastly going to catch that squirrel) or on that remaining push to achieve the summit, a breathable jacket is essential. We examined the breathability of those jackets by sporting each one throughout high-output actions. We wore them biking, working, snowboarding, snowboarding, and climbing. We thought of air flow options that assist regulate your core temperature when transferring quick, akin to armpit vents, sleeves that may simply be pushed up, and two-way zippers.
Thinner jackets do not preserve you as heat, however they’re additionally usually extra breathable. If a jacket has much less down, by definition, there may be much less insulating materials that may lure your physique warmth. The Mountain Hardwear Ghost Whisperer is an ideal instance of this. This ultralight jacket vents warmth higher than the thicker and hotter down jackets we examined.
The Arc’teryx Cerium has thinner artificial insulation underneath the arms and on the highest of the shoulders. Whereas the general efficiency of this jacket by way of breathability did not blow us out of the water, we did discover the thinner insulating materials underneath the armpits helped with breathability.
The Rab Electron Professional was the one jacket with two-way zippers to help in air flow. This mannequin lets you unzip the jacket from the highest, backside, or each on the similar time, which helps a ton with breathability.
Many producers additionally sew thinner baffles into high-heat areas to help in breathability. The Patagonia Down Sweater and Rab Microlight Alpine each have smaller baffles within the armpit space because of this. Whereas down would not evaluate to a extremely breathable fleece, we discovered each of those jackets are breathable sufficient whereas climbing, biking, and customarily transferring round.
One other nice approach to vent a jacket is to push up the sleeves. The Rab Electron Professional has essentially the most stretch within the wrists, and it accomplishes this with a pair of triangle-shaped elastic items. This enables the wrists to be tighter however stretch farther than your common wrist cuff.
Whereas it is fairly simple to push the sleeves up on most of those jackets, just a few have been too tight to push them up as far. The Mountain Hardwear Ghost Whisperer has tighter arms, and we weren’t in a position to push the sleeves up as far, particularly with a fleece beneath it. As a facet word, that is immediately contradictory to the findings from our girls’s down jacket testers and nearly definitely correlates with relative forearm circumference. If we have been to measurement up on any of those males’s jackets, we’d accomplish that with the Ghost Whisperer. A bigger measurement would clear up the minor issues our male testers had with pushing up the arms.
Conclusion
Having a heat, insulating jacket is a vital a part of any cold-weather layering system. Making the fitting resolution when buying a down jacket can seem to be a frightening job. We purpose to information you thru the jargon to let you realize which jackets are the warmest, most comfy, transportable, climate resistant, and breathable so you may make an knowledgeable resolution. We hope our in-depth breakdown of those down jackets will allow you to determine which one will work finest for you. As down jackets preserve getting lighter and hotter, we’ll proceed to remain on high of recent developments and current our findings right here.